Emergence

Intermediate Members
Emergence

John Conway placed a black Go stone on a board in the mathematics common room at Cambridge. He placed a white one beside it, then another black. He tested rules.

1968. Conway, a thirty-year-old algebraist with wild hair and a hunger for play, had inherited a problem from John von Neumann: find the simplest set of rules that could produce complex, unpredictable behavior. Von Neumann's own solution required twenty-nine possible states per cell and thousands of rules. Conway wanted something a child could follow.

For a year and a half, he and his colleagues ran experiments on the Go board during afternoon tea. They tried dozens of rule sets, tracking each generation of cells by hand, swapping stones for pennies when the configurations grew too large. Most rule sets died immediately, the cells freezing into static patterns or blinking out within a few generations. Others exploded without limit and filled the board with noise.

Then Conway isolated three rules. A cell with fewer than two neighbors dies. A cell with more than three neighbors dies. An empty cell with exactly three neighbors comes alive. Everything else stays.

His colleague Richard Guy, visiting Cambridge to help track patterns, told Conway one afternoon: "My blinker is walking."

Five cells had shifted one square diagonally. They had moved. Nobody designed movement into those rules. The rules said only: live, die, be born. Movement appeared nowhere in the specifications. Conway named the pattern a glider and spent the next weeks crashing gliders into each other in forty different configurations to see what the collisions produced.

Martin Gardner published the Game of Life in his October 1970 Scientific American column. It generated more reader mail than any article in the magazine's history. Programmers worldwide wrote simulations. Within months, the three rules had produced self-replicating patterns, logic gates, and structures capable of universal computation: a system that could, in principle, calculate anything any computer can calculate. Three rules about birth and death on a grid.

The glider lived in none of those rules. It lived in their arrangement.

The Why

Emergence is the appearance of properties in a system that no individual component carries. A single neuron cannot think. A hundred billion neurons, connected in specific patterns, produce consciousness. The property exists only in the whole. It exists in none of the parts.

George Henry Lewes coined the term in 1875, in the second volume of his Problems of Life and Mind. He drew a line between two types of effects. Resultants follow predictably from their causes, the way two vector forces produce a calculable third. Emergents arise from combination without displaying their components in action. Water served as his example: hydrogen burns, oxygen supports combustion, and neither is wet. The wetness cannot be deduced. It can only be discovered after it arrives.

For creatives, Emergence names the moment the finished work contains something the maker never placed there. A painter completes a canvas and a theme surfaces that existed in no individual brushstroke. A novelist finishes a draft and a pattern connects scenes written months apart with no conscious plan. The property lives in the arrangement of elements and the density of their interaction.

Read more

Create a free account to read this mental model and access all members-only content.

Subscribe
Already have an account? Sign in
Great! Next, complete checkout for full access to The Mental Models Club.
Welcome back! You've successfully signed in.
You've successfully subscribed to The Mental Models Club.
Success! Your account is fully activated, you now have access to all mental models.
Success! Your billing info has been updated.
Your billing was not updated.